Hall of Fire-a shaky firewoman

[Elanor]

You guys,
I just started filling in for Eru in the book club, where LotR is being read and I reallllllly need some feedback because I'm well aware my speculations on the chapters aren't quite as smooth as Eru's. Please check it out and tell me if I need to approach it from a different angle

[Lomadia]

I think you're doing a fine job, but your questions are mostly about minor events. That's what's great about reading chapter by chapter: you're able to stop and ponder the little things. But in addition to this, it might be nice to have some questions that pertain to the major themes of the story. Good job, Elanor!